CALL FOR PAPERSVolume 3Issue 1Submit Research
Criminal LawResearch ArticleOPEN ACCESSPEER REVIEWED

AI Hallucinations and the Doctrine of Judicial Invalidity: Rethinking Accountability for Fabricated Precedents in Indian Adjudication

Volume
3
Issue
1
Pages
1–12
Published
Nov 2026
0
0
4
PDF Preview1–12
Loading preview…

Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence can produce citations that look authoritative and do not exist. In 2026 the Supreme Court of India confronted the consequences in two decisions. In Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao, it declared that a trial court's reliance on fabricated judgments is misconduct and not an error of judgment. In Pooja Ramesh Singh v. Jammu and Kashmir Bank Ltd., it set aside insolvency orders resting on hallucinated precedent and held that such a decision is no decision in the eyes of the law. This essay examines the doctrinal basis, scope and consequences of that declaration. It argues that the rule can be reconciled with the established nullity doctrines, especially the principle that a decision must rest on a lawful foundation, but that its categorical formulation, under which even an iota of fabricated material vitiates a decision, sits uneasily with the principles of materiality and prejudice that govern appellate intervention. It further argues that classifying reliance on fabricated precedent as misconduct in every case risks collapsing the distinction between negligence and culpability that Indian service jurisprudence has long maintained for judicial officers. The essay proposes a graduated framework combining verification duties, institutional safeguards, proportionate sanctions and protection for litigants who bear the cost of invalidation.

Authors
KA
Komal Agarwal
Dr Ambedkar Global Law Institute, Tirupati
Keywords
AI hallucinationsdoctrine of judicial invalidityfabricated precedentsIndian adjudicationmateriality and prejudice
References
No references listed.

Related Research